You and I are stupid people:
What a minute, the flash is ready!
Relief of an agitated chest,
An unreasonable, harsh word.

Speak up when you're angry
Everything that excites and torments the soul!
Let us, my friend, be angry openly:
The world is easier - and more likely to get bored.

If prose in love is inevitable,
So let's take a share of happiness from her:
After a quarrel so full, so tender
The return of love and participation ...

Analysis of the poem "You and I are stupid people" by Nekrasov

The personal life of N. Nekrasov was rather strange and caused constant ridicule and gossip in society. The poet in his youth fell madly in love with A. Panaeva, who at that time was already married. Nekrasov was able to achieve reciprocity and from 1846 he lived in the same house with his spouses. Such an unusual development of the novel often led to violent quarrels and scandals. Both lovers were very quick-tempered people, so any little thing was enough for the next conflict. However, these disagreements were always temporary, after each quarrel, reconciliation quickly came. In 1851, Nekrasov wrote the poem "You and I are stupid people ...", in which he described his difficult relationship with Panaeva.

Nekrasov immediately gives an apt definition of himself and his beloved - "stupid people." That is how they were perceived by the surrounding society. After all, Panaeva's husband was well aware of their love relationship, which took place in his house. Therefore, he, too, can be called a "stupid person." In the 19th century, such a relationship was simply unthinkable. But Nekrasov does not seem to care too much about how his novel is perceived in society. He explains the "stupidity" by excessive irritability ("What a minute, then the flash is ready!"). He confirms that the cause of a serious conflict is "an unreasonable, harsh word." The poet was tormented by jealousy and often arranged stormy explanations. Panaeva, feeling right, did not answer. In their hearts, they could tell each other a lot of superfluous things.

Nekrasov, after five years of original life together, already had experience in such relationships. Therefore, he turns to his beloved with a request not to keep irritation in himself, but to immediately express what has accumulated in his soul. He encourages her to "get angry openly." The longer the anger builds up, the stronger and longer the scandal will be. If you let it splash out more often, then reconciliation will come faster. Probably, the constant presence of her lawful husband led Nekrasov to such a thought. It is unlikely that the lovers spoke openly about their relationship with him. Hidden life led to forced silence. Frank conversations began when the lovers were alone.

Nekrasov is even grateful to quarrels (“prose of love”), because after them reconciliation always comes, emphasizing the strength of mutual feelings.

The poet, even in lyrical works, strove for a real depiction of reality. The poem "You and I are stupid people" is an example of Nekrasov's love lyrics. It reflects the author's deeply personal experiences.

Nekrasov's private life was condemned by most of his contemporaries. After all, the young man fell in love with the wife of his friend, struck up a relationship with her, and subsequently lived under the same roof with his chosen one Avdotya Panaeva and her lawful husband Ivan. This love triangle, not hidden from other eyes, lasted for almost sixteen years. Its apogee and at the same time the guarantee of the end was the appearance of a common son and his quick death.

The lyricist devoted a cycle to the scandalous novel. One of the most striking of them is "You and I are stupid people", created in 1851. It was then that a certain misunderstanding began between the lovers, there were signals of what was on the threshold. They became frequent mutual accusations.

Difficult relationships are described in one deep phrase, which states that every minute there is a flash between the couple. But sometimes one thoughtless word or too strict look is enough for resentment. In this case, a solution to this problem is proposed: you need to immediately say that you don’t like the chosen one, and not accumulate irritation for years, turning it into the strongest fire of the soul. After all, a small fire can be extinguished by barely blowing on a candle, and it is not always possible to put out a huge fire, and it leaves behind only ashes and emptiness.

At the same time, a peculiarity was noted in such everyday quarrels, from which it is unrealistic to get away. After all, they are able to give new sensations, a breath of fresh air. The author believes that after them love is especially tender. The main thing is that reconciliation follows. A small discord will not destroy the relationship, but not stopped in time will lead to the complete collapse of the relationship.

The work is built from three stanzas. First, a picture is drawn, this is a description of the state of the quarreled immediately after the exchange of reproaches. It is motionless, without development - not a single verb is used here. This is a situation that needs to change. After the reader, on the contrary, will meet a lot of movement. This is an appeal to the heroine. The lyrical hero asks her to report everything that she does not like.

The third part is again static. Here the expectation of peace is described: only one verb form is used in the imperative mood "let's take" in combination with the noun "happiness". Again, it does not imply active actions.

The entire text is built on metaphors, such as "prose of love", which make it possible to understand the emotional experiences of the hero. You can also see several epithets that convey the attitude of lovers after the scandal. These are phrases such as "excited chest." Alliteration allows you to literally hear the barbs ringing in silence.

The three-foot anapaest with a feminine rhyme makes the rhythm smooth and even melodious. This technique helps to look at everything from the side.

Although these lines are dedicated to one woman, Nekrasov, in her person, appeals to everyone with an appeal to protect their feelings and not bring trifles to big problems that can no longer be approached.

Analysis of the poem "You and I are stupid people ..."

You and I are stupid people:

What a minute, the flash is ready!

Relief of an agitated chest,

An unreasonable, harsh word.

Speak up when you're angry

Everything that excites and torments the soul!

Let us, my friend, be angry openly:

The world is easier - and more likely to get bored.

If prose in love is inevitable,

So let's take a share of happiness from her:

After a quarrel so full, so tender

The return of love and participation ...

Poem by N.A. Nekrasov “You and I are stupid people”, first published in Sovremennik in 1851, addressed to A.Ya. Panaeva and is included in the so-called "Panaevsky cycle". The poet was 22 years old when he met A.Ya. Panaeva. She was 24 years old. Yesterday's proletarian, a literary vagabond, of course, at first he did not even dare to dream of the favor of such a brilliant lady. Her husband married her when Avdotya Yakovlevna was not yet nineteen, "almost in order to flaunt a beautiful wife in front of friends and walk with her to music in Pavlovsk." It was not easy for N.A. Nekrasov this woman. Out of desperation, he almost rushed into the Volga, but he was not such a person to fall behind. This duel lasted from 1843 to 1848, when she finally became his wife. But by this time A.Ya. Panaeva and N.A. Nekrasov were already completely different people.

The poem "You and I are stupid people ..." is about love, but love is not romantic, enthusiastic. Key words that speak about relationships A.Ya. Panaeva and N.A. Nekrasov, - “minute”, “flash”, “excites and torments the soul”, “share of happiness”, “return of love”.

There are two heroes in the poem: he and she, the lyrical hero and his beloved. The poem "You and I are stupid people ..." - the appeal of the lyrical hero to his beloved. ON THE. Nekrasov uses the appeal ("my friend"), verbs in the imperative mood ("speak").

This lyrical work can be divided into two parts: 1) a description of life, quarrels; 2) the appeal of the lyrical hero to his beloved (request, offer of compromise).

In this poem, consonant sounds [w], whistling, are repeated. Alliteration helps convey the ardor of a quarrel, indignation, indignation. In addition, hissing and whistling sounds affect the sound of the poem, slowing it down, making it more drawn out. Undoubtedly, the poetic size - an anapaest that conveys duration - was also chosen by the author not by chance.

ON THE. Nekrasov long and painfully loved the writer A.Ya. Panaev. He sings in his poems of deep love, mutual understanding and friendship of those who love. However, life is complex and tragic, and N.A. Nekrasov often talk about the dramatic pages of their love. The poet writes about this in the poem "You and I are stupid people ...". Heavy quarrels very often occurred between them, but love won, and they reconciled again. The poet here refers to Panaeva, calling both stupid due to frivolous quarrels that flare up like a match.

He asks her not to collect irritation, anger, resentment in herself, not to accumulate it, but to give them an outlet. It is better to shout out, to speak openly, not to conceal, and then it will become easy on the soul, and there will be no secrets between them. After all, "the world is easier - and more likely to get bored." And if there is a prose of life in love, then happiness can also be extracted from it: after a quarrel, love flares up even more.

“You and I are stupid people ...” Nikolai Nekrasov

You and I are stupid people:
What a minute, the flash is ready!
Relief of an agitated chest,
An unreasonable, harsh word.

Speak up when you're angry
Everything that excites and torments the soul!
Let us, my friend, be angry openly:
The world is easier - and more likely to get bored.

If prose in love is inevitable,
So let's take a share of happiness from her:
After a quarrel so full, so tender
The return of love and participation ...

Analysis of Nekrasov's poem "You and I are stupid people ..."

Nekrasov's personal life was condemned by many of his acquaintances. The thing is that the novice writer not only fell in love with a married woman, but also moved to live in her house, sharing shelter with her lawful spouse. The insane and blatantly impudent affair with Avdotya Panaeva lasted almost 16 years, and its culmination was the birth of a common child who lived only a few weeks. After his death, the relationship between the lovers began to deteriorate, and soon they parted.

Nekrasov himself considered one of the reasons for the gap to be the unbearable atmosphere that reigned in the Panaevs' house. He was jealous of his beloved for his lawful spouse, and she periodically staged ugly scenes with swearing and breaking dishes. It is noteworthy that this did not at all prevent this unusual trio from getting along well when it came to work. Panaev and Nekrasov during this period revived the Sovremennik magazine, and Avdotya was the owner of a literary salon, where meetings with young writers and poets were held regularly. By the way, in the network of Avdotya Panaeva, who at that time was considered one of the most attractive women in St. Petersburg, many writers, including Fyodor Dostoevsky, pleased. However, she reciprocated only Nekrasov, becoming not only his mistress, but also a like-minded person. It was with her participation that the so-called "Panaev cycle" of works was created, which included not only poems, but also Nekrasov's stories. The author dedicated part of his creations to the chosen one, and among them is the poem “You and I are stupid people ...”, written in 1851. At this time, the poet's romance with Avdotya Panaeva was in full swing, but the first signs of the impending separation were already making themselves felt. They were expressed in the constant quarrels of lovers, and Nekrasov characterizes these difficult relationships with one capacious phrase: “What is a minute, then the flash is ready!”. Indeed, one thoughtless word or an insufficiently tender look could provoke a litter. Therefore, turning to his chosen one, Nekrasov asks: “Speak, when you are angry, everything that excites and torments your soul!” The author believes that if from the very beginning you do not restrain your irritation and give it the opportunity to splash out, then outbursts of anger will be less violent. Yes, and he himself will be able to stop in time, without bringing the situation to a scandal.

At the same time, Nekrasov sees a special charm in such everyday quarrels, which he considers inevitable., but at the same time believes that they can also bring a special piquancy to the relationship of two people in love. “After a quarrel, the return of love and participation is so full, so tender…,” the poet believes.

In the first line of this poem, which gives the name, the hero declares that he is with her - with his beloved, just stupid. And then he explains this statement. In a minute, a "flash" is ready, that is, a surge of emotions. And as we understand further - negative. But this sharp, often unreasonable word immediately brings relief to both of them. That is, lovers cannot hide not only pleasant feelings, but also their anger and irritation.

In the second stanza, the hero addresses his beloved with a call to speak out. When she is angry, worried and tormented, and her soul is restless, then it is better to speak out. It is clear that she will not express the most pleasant, but the narrator is ready to accept everything. He calls her affectionately "my friend", asks to be open. But not only to her this request, but also to himself. Do not create artificially beautiful relationships, behind which repressed anger boils, claims and misunderstandings grow.

How often people seriously quarrel over the last drop, which can be any little thing! And all because they did not speak sincerely to each other, did not sort out the dubious situation, and everyone understood it in their own way, everyone was offended ... Such a “peaceful” existence is painful. And in general, just a peaceful state without claims and questions may mean that people are afraid to touch on difficult topics, remain at a distance from each other. And any world, like any quarrel, can get boring. It's good to have a change.

The third stanza is more philosophical. It speaks of the inevitability of prose in love, that is, life. But the author urges to take a “share” of happiness from her. And as for the inevitable quarrels ... then after them it is so wonderful to return to love again.

Of course, some words seem outdated to us in this 1851 poem (for example, “participation”), but the feelings of the characters are understandable. Nekrasov's advice is still relevant today.

Analysis of the poem You and I are stupid according to plan

Perhaps you will be interested

• Analysis of the poem Would be ill properly Akhmatova

  The main motive of the poem "It would be good to get sick" is memory and a return to the past. The work is imbued with the desire to get sick, and not just get sick, but get sick “as it should”.

• Analysis of the poem From the wilds of the fogs timidly Feta

  Afanasy Fet greatly valued the opportunity to engage in agriculture, he loved to spend time among nature, which inspired him with its beauty. In letters to close friends, he often

• Analysis of the poem Neighbor Lermontov (8th grade, 1837)

  The main theme of "The Neighbor" is an image of the spiritual experiences of the lyrical hero, experienced in prison solitary dungeons, expressing the life-giving influence of the word of poetry on the human soul.

• Analysis of the poem Ogorodnik Nekrasov

  The work Ogorodnik was published by Nekrasov at the end of the first half of the 19th century and immediately joined the ranks of love lyrics.

• Analysis of the poem The Twilight of Freedom by Mandelstam

  The work is an expression of the anxieties and forebodings that gripped the poet, who accepted the revolution, when he was able to experience in his own experience what the new society that the idealists dreamed of was like.